Celeste Berke Knisely, homeCeleste Berke
KniselySALES METHODOLOGY TRAINER
Talk about your team

If Every Rep Starts the Clock at a Different Time, What Is Your Win Rate Really Telling You?

Pulled right from my own discovery calls to help others who may be in the same spot - and who have that inkling that something needs to CHANGE.

Your board asks for your win rate. So does every investor and every vendor worth talking to should ask too.

But do you know when that number starts counting?.....

The Call

A sales leader told me recently that their win rate was pretty good. I asked what it was (number seemed high when they said it), so then I asked where they start counting that number from.

"From when our reps are ready to send a proposal"

Wait. So every deal a rep didn't feel good that yet hasn't gone to proposal doesn't count? No wonder the number looked good. I asked about before that moment in the pipeline and it got really fuzzy. If you are only counting the deals the reps believe will close, that is not accurate reporting and is a bit of a free for all, right?

The Insight

Win rate gets treated like a fact. It's the first number on the board slide.

But it's only as real as the moment the clock starts. And on many teams, that moment is a bit of a grey area. Meaning, it's not defined, so everyone runs it a bit differently.

So deals get cleared out early or added late stage, or held onto forever, and some never count against the win rate at all. Everyone is looking at the same number through a different lens.

When the clock starts on a rep's gut feeling, you're not measuring how well your team wins. You're measuring how confident your reps feel. We say it in our paper The Modern Sales Org: "The forecast measures how confident your reps are, not what the buyer has actually committed to."

So what do we suggest? Pick the moment the clock starts, and make it the same for everyone. Agree on three to five things that have to be true before a deal goes in the pipeline - things the buyer said and did, not how the rep feels.

Then review every deal against the same questions, every week. What's going on in the buyer's business? What problem did the rep find, what is it costing them and what's causing it? What did the buyer agree to do next?

Now your win rate means something. And you'll see the deals that were never real in the first place.

The Read

For its 2024 State of Sales report, Salesforce surveyed 5,500 sales professionals. Only 35% completely trust the accuracy of their own company's data.

Your win rate is built on that data. If every rep starts the clock whenever they want, it's hard to trust.

And when your win rate and pipeline can't be trusted.....you cannot forecast and plan for the future.

One quick thing you can do this week. Ask three of your reps, separately: "When does a deal start counting in our pipeline?"

If you get three answers.... stop...go back....define it and then track what happens to your DATA.

The Resource

The A Sales Growth Company Deal Review Framework gives your managers the same questions to ask on every deal, so you're looking at what the buyer actually said instead of how a rep feels about it. You want to know if a deal should be in commit - start diving into these questions.

https://salesgrowth.com/deal-review-framework/

Celeste Berke Knisely

Celeste Berke Knisely

Certified Gap Selling trainer and sales coach in Denver. 20+ years in sales and sales leadership, and she still runs her own discovery calls.

More about Celeste
Download the Problem Identification ChartThe #1 recommendation we have for a team moving into problem-centricity.
Email me the PIC