They can't tell me their win rate. But they know exactly when the training starts.
The Call
I have this call constantly. A leader wants to buy sales training. Somewhere in the first five minutes I attempt to dive into their problem environment to tie what they have told me, to a problem I solve that is showing up in the org. For this call, I ask what the team's attainment was.
Pause. "I'd have to go look."
They're at their desk. Screen right in front of them. Half the time they've already told me they track all of it, and that's usually true. It's in the CRM or on a dashboard somewhere. The calls are recorded. But some....they just can't say it out loud. The numbers.
Here's what they can say without looking anything up. When the training is. The dates they have set aside to roll out or do something with the team. That part is always exact.
The Insight
So the calendar date has been narrowed down, but the diagnosis isn't there at all and quite a bit of the time, I'm not sure anyone realizes that they skipped over a deeper dive into what's going on. Because they are looking through the lens that is comfortable to them.
What I've seen as the common thread. Hard workers, usually a top rep that was promoted and trying to replicate what they did as a rep with the team they are now building or have built themselves. And they're honest the second you throw this at them... My usual go to when someone doesn't know their number is to say..."if your win rate is about 25%, sales cycle lengths are not dragging, everyone on the team is above 80% of quota and average contract value is increasing, I'd venture to say you don't need to buy anything. Most of them come straight back with forecasting is weak, follow-up is poor, discovery is thin, and now, our win rate isn't where we want it to be.
Ok...we are getting somewhere. They know. They just may know it as a feeling instead of a number, because no one until me as has them to string it together to show them the case for change and what exactly is causing their problem environment.
Even after all of that, I still will get a message back with "but what is the training and how much is it".....(after some amazing follow up pinpointing their case, asking numbers to get to show them if they should even change and questions I'd like to dive into deeper to fully understanding because I don't know if training will even solve it!).....
I'll send a diagnosis. A free assessment. An exercise they can run with their own team next week that costs nothing. And the reply comes back - but what about the training!!!!!
It isn't stubbornness. Training is a thing you can buy, put on a calendar and report upward. A diagnosis is a thing you have to go do. Only one of those closes this quarter.
And nobody ever told them that reading their own numbers and diagnosis what was causing it - ALL of the reasons, and then creating a plan to attack that, to upskill the team, to embed a system, to repeat and coach and sustain was the job.
I have stopped holding against anyone. We take the person who sold the most, hand them a team, and never say out loud that the work is now a completely different job
The Read
There is a paper on exactly this. Benson, Li and Shue, "Promotions and the Peter Principle," in the Quarterly Journal of Economics. 38,843 sales workers. 131 firms. 1,553 promotions into management. The better someone sold, the worse they tended to manage.
The thing we used to pick managers predicts the opposite of what we are picking for. Fifty years of promoting the top rep, and a study with thirty eight thousand people in it telling us we have had it backwards the whole time.
So here's something you can try. Without opening a tab or a dashboard, say your attainment - by team. By rep if you can. Then your win rate. Then how long a deal is taking to close.
If you had to go look, more training is not going to fix what is happening on your team. Somebody has to be paid to look at this every week, and kudos if you were that rep prompted to manager - that is now you. A training isn't going to save you. Training without reinforcement or a system in place is a waste. It's a check the box and a really expensive exercise that rarely moves the needle alone. Understanding the complexities of how to buy, what you are solving for and how to embed it so not only metrics move but behaviors change for the long run is the job of a manager. But it's not easily taught.
The Resource
We wrote up the whole argument. What the manager job actually is, why your best seller is usually the wrong person for it, and what it costs you when you get it wrong.
Before you dive in and push a rep to sell you the training - read this first.

