Celeste Berke Knisely, homeCeleste Berke
KniselySALES METHODOLOGY TRAINER
Talk about your team

This CEO Isn’t Reading Your Team’s Emails (And It's Not Because Email Doesn't Work)

Alessio Artuffo, CEO of Docebo, didn’t mess around in his post yesterday.

“I haven’t read an outbound email in a century. They’re awful. I delete 80% of my LinkedIn messages. Spam.”

Now we know he's not a century old, but the message was loud and clear. He's NOT reading them. And he went on to say, he had 16 more cold messages in his LinkedIn inbox all trying to sell him IT solutions.

Being in and around the space, it's no secret. It's getting hard to get attention of anyone (I also send emails, so I get it). But the truth is, he’s not saying email doesn’t work. He’s saying the way it’s being used doesn’t work and he's tuned out.

Why Top Leaders Are Tuning Out

Inboxes are overflowing (er...junk inboxes?). And the reality is, most teams' pipelines are hurting. I've yet to talk to a team who isn't. Even I'm seeing a lull. It's eerily quiet for many teams. And for others, the double whammy is - their win rates were already so low, that not having any pipe is hitting them hard. The knee-jerk response from leadership? More. More sequences. More volume. More activity. More of all of it.

In theory, I get it. It's simple. It takes 7-15 ish touches to land with someone. If one email didn’t land, maybe seven more will. Maybe it's timing. Maybe it's the value. Maybe it's the person. But when that cadence turns into a “spray and pray” way of attack with little to no thought behind it, leaders like Alessio tune out.

Yet lead gen agencies are on the rise. Message after message about sending tens of thousands of emails per month - people clinging to these desperate attempts to finally get a chance, that somehow - the more concept is going to be the magic bullet that fixes all. Sure, the activity is measured, but the messages? Sloppy. Surface. Scraped from activity. Actually, I've taken to going into my junk folder to respond to a few a day. I'm shocked I never get an email back!!! Like you messaged ME.

And now imagine that you are an executive who sees hundreds of these messages daily. It becomes noise.

The Easy Button Is Breaking

As Anthony Natoli put it in the comment section of Alessio Artuffo's post, “Lots of people invested in tools to hit the easy button and abused the original purpose.”

What was meant to help sellers think smarter turned into a way to avoid thinking altogether. Jacki Leahy called it: “The bar has never been lower. And the resources have never been higher.”

This isn’t a resource issue. It’s a leadership issue.

Last summer I chatted with a VP of Sales in person who said, "I know, I hate outbound and I make my team send mass messages - yet I never respond to any message I receive".

Wait, what?

Desperation Smells Stinky.

You can smell it in the inbox. I can smell it. I've actually gotten some really bizarre emails as of late. People who are running discounts, giving away services - FOR FREE - just to get a response. Newsletters of names I haven't seen in years now sending emails all of a sudden.

More isn't the answer; it's that what is being sent has fundamentally ticked off so many buyers that you have to be exceptional to stand out (shoutout to Will Aitken and Keenan for their Gap Prospecting book). While the bar is so low for good messaging, the bar is also so high to get people to actually WANT to open one.

And the cherry on top; the sellers and VPs that I talk to who tell me they solve for inefficiencies or to save time. I mean, imagine going up to your CEO of a Fortune 500 company and telling them you have to spend $10k so you all can save time. Laughable. That's not a business case, that's a you problem.

This isn't an article about how to write an effective email, it's more so a wake up call that even the good/outstanding messages are so buried under a heap of junk that top leadership is likely hiding. They are fed up. I mean, all that is left is to go to their house. (kidding)

So How Do We Fix It? (Emphasis on All Sales Leaders)

Alessio laid out what his team leans on: phone-heavy, intent-driven, calls that educate, hyper-targeted accounts, constant personalization. That’s what works for them. He said they iterate as month after month things change so rapidly, they have to test and test.

But this is just one POV. There are many ways to reach executives - and yes, email still works too. Just got a CRO to respond myself the other day to one, so they DO read them....sometimes. The point is, if your team can’t even nail the basics, they don’t have a shot no matter the channel.

The basics are about the discipline:

  • Know what you solve for - stop leading with product. For real. Stop. Product-centric selling puts all the work on the buyer, and most buyers don’t even know the depth of their own problems.
  • Quantify the impact - in a tight environment, nobody buys unless they can calculate the risk or what is happening as a result. It's rarely about ROI, but rather, COI. If your team can’t connect the dots between the problem and its business impact, they’re toast. Why does it matter to the buyer is a great question to ask your reps during deal review.
  • Do the research - shrink the ICP, study it, and show up knowing their world better than they do. Your buyer should say...."wait, have you worked in this industry before". I mean, I've studied my dad's work for 40 years, so I'm basically a dr....so...
  • Target a unique problem - not just any pain point (hello all the teams "selling to pain" and letting the buyer "tell you what they need"), but one that’s made worse by the environment they’re operating in. Like what is the problem you solve for their business...at the business level?
  • Get maniacal about conversion - once an opportunity is in the pipe, leaders need to coach their reps hard on discovery, not just push for more at the top of the funnel. But if reps don't even know how to run a diagnostic discovery - that's a whole separate convo.

It's wonky donky out there. AI has perhaps made everyone a lil crazed....the easy button mentality is rampant, the "let's wait and see mentality is strong".... But what this CEO said is truth. Many senior leaders are just straight up skipping the inbox.

The real question isn’t “why aren’t CEOs reading your team’s emails?” It’s “why aren’t leaders teaching their sellers how to make those emails worth reading in the first place - especially now?”

Celeste Berke Knisely

Celeste Berke Knisely

Certified Gap Selling trainer and sales coach in Denver. 20+ years in sales and sales leadership, and she still runs her own discovery calls.

More about Celeste
Download the Problem Identification ChartThe #1 recommendation we have for a team moving into problem-centricity.
Email me the PIC