Celeste Berke Knisely, homeCeleste Berke
KniselySALES METHODOLOGY TRAINER
Talk about your team

Why Sales Leaders Cling to ROI When They Should Be Confronting COI

And what that says about what's really holding them back

"But, what is the ROI on this?"

When I present a recommendation of services and pricing, I first gain agreement on the problems the buyer has (current state), where they want to be (future state) and what that Gap is and show their COI- cost of inaction. I gather all of that during discovery so I have a solid case.

50% of the time, after I present a recommendation to a prospect, I'm asked the question...."what is the ROI"?

Me. Breathe. (Before I give away more here....).

I want you to close your eyes and think about the last time you purchased a car.

Did you ever utter the words...."so what's the ROI on this car"?

NO....because, that's silly.

Most people buy a car to solve a problem: No car. No transportation. Unreliable old car. Too many car problems, high rate of repairs....out of warranty, etc.

Unless it's a collector's item, focusing on ROI for the purchase of a car is nonsensical. How would a car salesman respond? They may laugh, like, um, you do know a car depreciates, right? Instead, The focus should be on what is happening NOW that is urgent so you see why you have to buy asap.

I digress....

Unpacking Defaulting to ROI

So let's dive in and unpack why the focus on ROI is actually hurting you as a sales leader.

When most sales leaders are buying something to fix their team...maybe that's a new methodology, training, tech, or the latest and greatest ai tool, the question that never fails to come up is: “What’s the ROI?”

It sounds smart(ish). Strategic. Like real C-Suite/Boardroom like conversation. Responsible. But a lot of the time, it’s just a little safety blanket.

Because what you’re really afraid to ask is:

“Do I actually believe my team can change?” (If the prospect is reading this whom I asked this question to recently....hi.)

And if you’re not sure about the answer to that… ROI becomes a really convenient place to dig your heels into.

ROI Is The Safe Question

COI is the hard one.

ROI keeps you in what we call a "future state". All sellers love to live here, because it's Narnia and where our product lives that makes your life great. But it's a what COULD happen. What MAY improve. What someone else SHOULD do.

COI or Cost of Inaction, forces you to look at what’s already happening (and lemme tell you, when a seller does their job, it can be a really big slap in the face to see, so buckle up):

Things I focus on (because I know the problems I solve) look like this:

  • poor win rates
  • weak pipeline
  • low or disparate quota attainment (usually it's a few reps carrying the whole team, or no one is making it)
  • really long sales cycle lengths
  • low average sales price

These aren’t a hypothetical world. They’re facts. They are happening. You see them in your dashboards. You feel them in your pipeline reviews. Your team feels it too. Your forecast sucks.

But naming it? Doing something about it? That’s scary.

Because if you move forward… now it’s on you, and potentially a little weak feeling in the pit of your stomach of....can the team actually change (separate conversation on that - FEAR).

ROI Gives You A Way To Not Make A Decision

Here’s how this usually goes if you are in sales leadership.

You know the team needs help. You’ve been thinking it and maybe DIY'ing it for months. You see missed quota targets, the lack of (all the things). Perhaps you've even implemented sales training/reinforcement before and it fell flat.

But you go at it again as you know something has to change. You start to explore options and POOF, the actual spend and spend per rep presented to you shocks you. So you quickly recoil.

Then the doubt creeps in:

  • What if they don’t adopt it?
  • What if we spend all this money and nothing changes?
  • What if this exposes something deeper going on?

So instead of confronting those fears, you ask for ROI. Give me the numbers. Show me the upside. Convince me this will work. Who else has this worked for?

Then you start to think your team is special. That your case is unique (I mean, no offense), and that somehow, without seeing an ROI, that you can't trust that it will work for you - you unicorn!

But you’re not waiting on proof really. It's more so for the feeling that it’s “safe” to make the call so you keep your job and everyone ends up in Narnia.

The truth? It’s not about ROI at all

It really comes down to two things:

What is the cost of inaction. Is the cost of inaction GREATER than the cost of change? Do you believe it?

And two. Belief.

Do you believe your team can change? Do you believe they’re willing to be coached, to try new things, to lean in?

Are you?

When you focus on the cost of inaction, there really can't be a downside if you do all the things. You are already losing by doing nothing.

Most likely, ROI will follow.

And I think deep down you know that.

The real question isn’t “What will this give me?”

It’s “What is this already costing me? (what is my real cost of inaction and do I believe that those numbers the rep shared about my cost of inaction are TRUE).

Until you’re ready to answer that, nothing changes.

Celeste Berke Knisely

Celeste Berke Knisely

Certified Gap Selling trainer and sales coach in Denver. 20+ years in sales and sales leadership, and she still runs her own discovery calls.

More about Celeste
Download the Problem Identification ChartThe #1 recommendation we have for a team moving into problem-centricity.
Email me the PIC