Celeste Berke Knisely, homeCeleste Berke
KniselySALES METHODOLOGY TRAINER
Talk about your team

Dirty Boxing Your Way to Win the Month Isn’t a Winning Strategy

First up - what the heck is dirty boxing?

In combat sports, (think MMA or boxing) dirty boxing is when a fighter throws short punches while grabbing the back of the head and swinging just enough to keep control. So it's kinda like cheating a bit by hanging on, and getting in those jabs and winning the match by the little work around.

Sales teams do this too.

I'm in a sales cycle with a company and the buyers are unintentionally, funny. They threw something out on two occasions that made me stop and think...hmmm, this is what many teams are doing.

“We’ve been dirty boxing our way to win the month.”

Where Most Sales Teams Fail

Now this is where I have an advantage over what a lot of teams are taught. I had three leaders who taught me - define everything. So when a buyer says..."we've been dirty boxing our way to win the month" two things come up for me.

What the heck is dirty boxing, and what is happening IN the business as a result. I want to know the answers to those, before I do what most sales people do - jump straight into product. "We can help you not dirty box your way to win the month with our feature and product - lemme show you".

Me, I pause and I asked what that actually "dirty boxing looks like" FOR THEM. Here’s what they said:

  • Discounting to push deals across the line at the end of the month
  • Last-minute promos to create urgency
  • Selling one-offs instead of systems
  • Skipping qualification and jumping right into value
  • Prioritizing volume over value - so in their case, they will go after 20-50 small transactional deals to win the month instead of selling a larger system (hello low acv - average contract value).

That’s not a strategy. That’s survival - and many of you - yes you and your teams, are doing this.

So what?

Why does it matter?

It only matters if all of what is happening above leads to a set of problems that have impacts.

Read that again.

The Problem Is Bigger Than Just a Bad Month

In this case, the company is PE-backed. They want an exit. I got that on the THIRD CALL. (for all of you who skip disco or think that you can get that within 15 mins). The PE firm has a targeted multiplier /valuation - their EBITDA isn't where it has to be, and the clock is ticking.

So we dug further to do the math. Again, the so what. If they continue to NOT CHANGE and dirty box - what happens?

Well, they did some math and came up with a number below $10M that it would cost them to dirty box their way to their top line number. That's an actual cost - spend - more headcount, discounts, freebies, giving things away, promos and and.....plus the kicker, their profitability.

My solution - less than $100k. Notice how I didn't start there?

Skipping Discovery

So when I hear that leadership allows teams to skip discovery, I think to myself....how in the heck are you helping your team with a long term strategy if you have no information to make a case on?

Here’s the interesting part. This opportunity - it started from a straight up cold call. When the SDR focused on the problems we solve for, the buyer agreed they have a long sales cycle.

We went from long sales cycles of 150+ days to fear of higher ups losing their jobs to what is happening in deals to pipeline creation and EBITDA targets and profit margins and the PE firm and and and.

Yet many reps are trained to hear - deals are taking too long - "oh cool, that's actually what we solve for - my CRM helps move deals through faster by ensuring reps...blah blah blah and we have a promotion going on right now".

Dirty Boxing Is a Leadership Issue

If your team is constantly scrambling to hit the number, that’s not just a sales problem it’s a leadership issue.

The culture rewards urgency over clarity and how you actually help your buyer. Activity over gathering the buyer input data. Quick wins over long-term growth - because what, it's too hard?

Leadership is hard. Diving into the nitty gritty is hard. The easy way is to dirty box.

Leadership ends up celebrating the outcome, not how the team got there. That’s how dirty boxing becomes the default.

If this sounds familiar, the good news is, you are not alone AND you can dig your way out of it.

But if your team:

  • Doesn’t know the root cause of your buyers’ problems
  • Can’t articulate business impact
  • Relies on volume to hit quota
  • Shows up to pipe and just says, I haven't heard but I'm keeping this in the pipeline
  • Celebrates surviving the month…

You're not scaling. You’re scrapping.

And eventually, scrapping stops working.

Dirty boxing is exhausting. Selling with purpose isn’t.

Celeste Berke Knisely

Celeste Berke Knisely

Certified Gap Selling trainer and sales coach in Denver. 20+ years in sales and sales leadership, and she still runs her own discovery calls.

More about Celeste
Download the Problem Identification ChartThe #1 recommendation we have for a team moving into problem-centricity.
Email me the PIC