If the Buyer Didn't Say It, Why Is It in Your Team's Commit?
*Every week I share what I pull from my own disco.
A lesson. A resource for you to ponder.*
VPs of Sales - that deal in commit just went dark.
Another one came back "lost to price"....and no one on your team can tell you if price was really why.
I ran a full discovery call (this is what I do for a living) and scored it on only what the buyer actually said.
25 out of 100.
So what is a 30 minute call getting your reps before the demo?
The Call
In the last few weeks I've talked to a handful of sales leaders who want their teams selling more. Who doesn't. They all described the back half of the deal the same way.
One told me deals go stale once they're moving forward - "ghosting happens" And when they lose, "at least people say because of price, but you never really know."
Another said the team shows the product and moves pretty quickly into a trial. Then the buyer doesn't want to move forward, and the questions that would have caught it two visits earlier never got asked.
Then I had a first call with a leader who wants to grow his team. He said his sellers are really good at the technical questions and present well, but thought they could go further in understanding the buyer's organization and what they're up against.
I snagged some initial rough numbers and a next yes, but this first call was really meaty around this buyer's world. While I lined up my next yes, a micro agreement from this prospect to keep things moving, I knew my discovery was super light.
Most teams are like that. The difference is, I know that I cannot move to any recommendation until I actually build a business case. However, the majority of teams we work with - even for complex sales, speed through a short disco and start talking capabilities and pricing. They scratch the surface, hear a need and think - let me show them. It turns into show and tell before anyone has built the case.
So I showed him what one call actually gets you.
To recap, I'd just run a full discovery with him, and at the end I still had to tell him: "I don't have enough of your business case to know, like, should you even buy anything right now."
Then I sent him a page with our own call scored on only what he'd told me: 25 out of 100. The only thing he'd clearly said yes to was an agreement he may have a problem early stages with conversions and that there was enough value to keep talking.
Let me stop here and say. Discovery is TOUGH. I've been talking about this with teams I'm currently working with. Buyers are doing a lot of research (hello internet and ai searches) so they are coming to the calls with an assessment done of their world, a thought about what they need and want to know how it works. It's a little funny to me because their buying behavior is usually the complete opposite of what they want their teams to do.
So in this case, I wanted to show this prospect that the limited time that we had together wasn't enough for me to say - this is how we'd solve your problem.....and sure as heck the one call his team was having wasn't enough to sell a few hundred thousand dollar solution.
After the lightbulb moment that our own discovery was surface, he said...."I get it, this was super helpful"
This is what I sent: our Deal Wheel, with an explanation of our call and why it was scored a 25 out of 100.
Oh, this is the A Sales Growth Company Deal Wheel. It's new. We no longer have stages in our pipeline. Everything is scored based on what the BUYER SAID.
The Insight
Most teams move a deal when the seller does something - discovery done, demo given, proposal sent. None of those needs the buyer to say anything.
So deals hit commit on the rep's read of the buyer. That's hopium....and it's where they go dark or get "lost to price."
We here at ASG - only move a deal on what the buyer said. Right, a departure from the norm.
But what about commit? What about stages? What about....
It's all based on the information the buyer says (which means your team has to ask) about their environment - hence Gap Selling. No full pie - no commit. Think about that for a second. This means that your commit stage most likely gets DRASTICALLY cut. Because none of it was true to begin with. It was...NO DEAL because NO DATA.
This isn't about MORE discovery. It's about using the time your team has during discovery to actually run a discovery that builds a case. And the wheel just exposes what is happening in disco. And maybe you're thinking more discovery is going to slow your cycles down. It doesn't. I'd argue it speeds up the post discovery and it also protects your commit.
Every single call I am on forecast accuracy is a hot topic. This solves for that.
Across the organizations we've worked with over the years, won deals averaged 74 days old. Lost deals sat open for 143.
It's the lost deals slowing you down, not the extra discovery.
The Read
In that same data, deals where the rep captured 92% of what the buyer told them - the problem, what it costs and what's causing it - averaged a 61% win rate. Deals with far less of it averaged 17% and 7%. (source: ASG / Noted Analytics data).
Here's a test for your next pipeline review. Pull up one deal headed for a demo or a proposal and ask the rep one question - where did the buyer say what this problem is costing them?
If the answer is "they agreed with me".....that's happy ears, and the deal isn't as far along as your CRM says.
The Resource
It's the ASG Deal Wheel. It's how I scored that call and how I run my own deals.
It has 13 slices, each one something only the buyer can tell you: the facts that set the stakes, the problem, what it does to the rest of the business, what's causing it, where they want to be, why it matters now, the size of the gap, what waiting costs, what changing takes, whether it's worth making room for, who decides and how, how they'll choose, and the next step they agreed to.
Every slice is scored on what the buyer SAID. Green means the buyer said it and it's defined. Yellow means they said it loosely, or just agreed with the rep. Red means we don't know. Gray means it hasn't come up yet.
What it does to the business, the size of the gap and what waiting costs count double.
The rep's hunches go off to the side and never move the score.
Nothing moves forward until 80% is green. If the buyer didn't say it, it's not part of the deal.
More on the ASG Deal Wheel - but if you are reading this far and nodding that you have a commit problem - I'd start to dive in to - what did the buyer say vs. what did the rep report out they asked.
PS. I'll run anyone's deal through - I keep putting it out there - who is going to take me up on it?

