Celeste Berke Knisely, homeCeleste Berke
KniselySALES METHODOLOGY TRAINER
Talk about your team

This Deal Wasn't Real. The Deal Review Proved It.

One call.

One lesson. One resource.

I was facilitating a deal review with a client recently when a rep brought forward an opportunity that had been sitting in the pipeline for months.

The prospect had asked for paperwork. Twice. So a few discovery calls had happened and the prospect asked for a contract (twice).

Then they disappeared. For months.

The rep wanted ideas on how to get the deal moving again.

But before we talked about follow-up emails, break-up emails, or phone calls, I started asking the questions I ask in every deal review.

The Rep Had Information. Just Not The Right Information.

I asked the rep to walk us through the current state - physical literal - the facts.

The rep knew the company had doubled in the number of professionals they had onboard.

The rep knew they were manually validating every single professional (so a manual process).

The rep knew they had aspirations to become a major player in their market.

The rep knew they wanted to automate parts of their process.

Then I asked: What are they trying to accomplish as a business? Silence.

What is their desired future state? Not sure.

How big are they trying to get? No idea.

What is the gap between where they are today and where they're trying to go? Errrr...not sure.

*I'd like to preface this - it's not an interrogation of the rep - it is to find out, did the rep seek to find the information, did the buyer not know the information, who owns what is going on, how did we ask the question, what did we skip, etc. This is a learning environment.

The Business Problem Wasn't Identified

As we continued digging, the rep kept coming back to the same thing.

"They manually their process."

That's useful information. But it's not a business problem. It's not really a reason a business will work over money to change. It's a process.

So I asked: What business problem is that creating? The team chimed in with what they thought. But no one knew the facts.

The entire opportunity had been built around what the prospect was doing and what they wanted.

Now, to be fair to the rep and the entire team - this opportunity had been in place way before the team created their Problem Identification Chart and had gone through training on Gap Selling and how to run a problem-centric discovery.

The Impacts Were Missing Too

You can deduce that the impacts were not captured as a business problem was identified. And without impacts to an org, there is a high probability that they are not changing! know.

At that point, the room started doing what sales teams do when discovery is incomplete.

The team started creating theories. Maybe they're worried about compliance, or their reputation...Maybe they're worried about growth. Maybe they're worried about onboarding.

The problem is none of those came from the buyer. They came from a guess.

The Deal Was Built On Assumptions

The deal wasn't stalled because the buyer got busy. The deal wasn't stalled because the rep needed a better follow-up strategy. The deal was stalled because we skipped the work that should have happened during discovery.

A gap was never established. The rep didn't identify a buyer-stated business problem. The rep wasn't able to quantify the impacts. And thus, the root causes were never connected to a business problem. The rep never got agreement around what happens if nothing changes.

And because of that, a case for change couldn't be created.

When the buyer stopped responding, there was nothing to go back to.

No buyer-owned reason to act.

This Is Why Buyer Input Data Matters

One of the reasons we run deal reviews the way we do is because they expose what's missing.

  • Can the rep explain the buyer's current state?
  • Can they explain the future state?
  • Can they explain the gap?
  • Can they explain the business problem?
  • Can they explain the impacts?
  • Can they explain what it stems from?
  • Can they explain the next micro-agreement they've earned?

If those answers aren't there, neither is the business case.

And when there's no business case, deals sit. They slip. They ghost. And eventually they die. And, your team isn't armed with any information to be able to hold up a mirror to the prospect about their current environment.

Follow up is generic - vs. "you said this problem is happening, causing this impact, stemming from this root cause - their environment, their metrics....their broken processes."

This deal wasn't real.

And again - we were reviewing a deal where discovery was done WAY before Gap Selling was implemented - the goal was to show the team that when a thorough discovery is missed, you have no leg to stand on to go back to a prospect to ask them why they are punting the can down the road. We HAVE to get someone to understand that ah-ha moment of what happens during discovery is vital to a deal.

Resource

If you want to see the framework we use during deal reviews, I've included our Buyer Input Data guide (BID).

Last-minute slips. Bloated pipelines. Board meetings spent explaining why the number didn’t land.

The root cause? Deals built on “vibes” - demo reactions, verbal commitments, and gut feelings instead of evidence.

When BID is missing, reps can’t prove urgency, managers can’t inspect reality, and leaders can’t trust the forecast. The result is unpredictable revenue, frustrated teams, and eroded board confidence.

This guide shows how Buyer Input Data (BID) replaces hope with proof by making buyer-validated intelligence the operating standard for every opportunity, review, and forecast.

Celeste Berke Knisely

Celeste Berke Knisely

Certified Gap Selling trainer and sales coach in Denver. 20+ years in sales and sales leadership, and she still runs her own discovery calls.

More about Celeste
Download the Problem Identification ChartThe #1 recommendation we have for a team moving into problem-centricity.
Email me the PIC