Leaders, If You’re Not Catching This in Discovery, You’re Already Forecasting Fiction
Yep, I'll go there!
If the first thing your reps do on a discovery call is pull up a slide deck, your quarter’s already off to a rough start.
And so is your pipeline.
Ok, I get it. Tons of PLG motions out there killing it, but eventually, you'll have to cross that chasm (I can never spell that word correctly), and not lean on your product. Your team will actually have to know what problems you solve and how to make a case so the buyer sees value in continuing the discussion.
And that happens in discovery.
I'm not saying decks are evil. I'm saying discovery isn't about your team.
And yet… We’ve all heard it:
“Let me share a little about us first…” Click. Slide 1. Cue 7 minutes of fluff and logos before the buyer says a word.
Shallow discovery and decks and demos without knowing anything about your buyer lead to a pipeline of fluff, low win rates (or inflated win rates because nothing is ever closed out) and you as a sales leader shaking your head.
It Always Starts in Discovery
Don't be fooled by talk times. Reps can talk less during discovery and it still be a poor discovery. For real.
I've been listening to team's calls and looking at conversions by stage and have noticed a few things.
- A massive drop off after discovery (we are talking 75-90% drop off).
This typically happens because reps do about 6-15 minutes of shallow discovery, and then jump right into the product.
The buyer now has all of the product information as well as all of the problem information so they are set and will make a decision or not on their own time.
- A pipeline that is full of fluff. Fluff being, opportunities that are not that.
As a sales leader you see coverage of 3-5x - I've seen millions sitting in pipes, yet when you start to peel back the layers, those "opportunities" never had any true discovery and potentially shouldn't even be in the pipe.
See how it always starts with discovery?
And when this happens, your future Q's are in trouble.
Mislabeling the Problem
I’ve seen too many teams mislabel this problem. They call it a pipeline issue. A market issue. A timing issue.
It’s not.
It’s a discovery quality issue. And no one’s inspecting the calls to catch it because, who has the time? (more on how we are fixing that later).
Instead:
- Opportunities are entering the CRM without a single business problem identified
- Reps are pitching solutions to “needs” instead of finding actual problems (hello churn)
- Follow-ups are based on hope, not impacts or an actual case that was made from great discovery
- Discovery calls aren't being coached or pulled apart from jump so reps actually learn what "good" looks like.
Red Light, Yellow Light, Green Light
So what can you do today as a sales leader to dive into your teams discovery?
Pick 2-3 calls and listen. Use the below chart to quickly assess the call. Not some fancy listening tool - your actual ears so you know what's going on. You can also use this CHART to do a quick tally.
Red flags? Think: the rep talks more than the buyer, ends with an “if we can show you” close, and yep… pulls up a deck in discovery.
Yellow? They asked surface-level questions, didn’t connect needs to business problems, and discovery felt like a checklist.
Green? They identified at least two real problems, dug into the impact, uncovered root cause, and mapped the current to future state.
That's Just A Start
Decks don't lead to sales, real discovery and creating a case for change that the buyer understands, agrees with and sees the value in does.
Decks are out, discovery is in.
It's time to get in and inspect.

